Last Updated on 3 November 2026 by FuturePerfect
In an earlier newsletter, I wrote about the Tuesday in March that belongs entirely to you. The CEO who calls before the board does. The commercial director who needs your wisdom more than another meeting. The Portfolio Executive life, which looks nothing like what most people imagine, is considerably better.
What I did not describe in detail is how you get from where you are now to that Tuesday. This newsletter is about that. Not the philosophy, not the reframe. The actual sequence.
Start With Problems, Not Positions
The single most important shift in how you approach potential clients is this: stop thinking about which role you could fill and start thinking about which problem you could solve.
An organisation creates a role after it decides what it needs and how to package it. By the time a role is advertised, the conversation about what was needed has already taken place without you. You are responding to a conclusion someone else reached, often with criteria that do not capture what you actually offer.
A problem is different. Every organisation has problems, often visible to an outside eye before it is fully apparent to those inside. And a senior professional with your depth of experience can often, within twenty minutes of a conversation with a founder or CEO, identify where the friction lies and what kind of thinking might address it.
Seeing is your entry point. Not your CV. Not your title history. Your ability to look at a business and understand something about its situation that the people running it have not yet articulated clearly for themselves.
The First Conversation
The first conversation with a potential client should not be a pitch. It should be an enquiry.
Your opening question is not: “I would love to explore whether there is a role for me here.” It is: “I have been following what you are building and am curious whether you face the challenge of [challenge] you may face in [specific area]. Is it worth a short chat?”
That framing does several things. It positions you as genuinely interested in their situation rather than as someone seeking a berth. It signals sector knowledge and attention. And it makes the conversation immediately valuable to them, regardless of whether it leads to an engagement.
Go into that first conversation with three things prepared. A clear understanding of the business and its current context. One or two specific observations about the challenges they are likely facing. And a genuine question, the kind only someone with real experience of similar situations would ask. The quality of your question in the first conversation is one of the strongest signals of the quality of thinking you will bring if they engage you.
From Conversation to Contribution
If the first conversation goes well, the next step is not to send a proposal. Instead, provide something of value which can lead to a further conversation.
This might be a brief document outlining your perspective on the challenge you discussed and some of the experiences you have had in organisations that faced the challenge. It might be an insight from a publication, a blog post or an article.
At this stage, what you are doing is demonstrating the quality of engagement. You are not selling. You are allowing the relationship to develop so that engagement becomes the natural next step rather than something that requires persuasion.
Most people skip this stage because it feels like giving value away for nothing. In my experience, it is the stage that makes the difference between a conversation that stays a conversation and one that becomes a client.
Understanding the Depth of the Challenge
This interaction aims to build enough of a relationship that you can return for a longer conversation where you can explore the depth of the challenge they face.
At this point, you are seeking to explore how important the challenge is to a potential client and to ask questions that demonstrate that you are an expert on the problem.
Questions you might ask could include:
· How long have you had this problem?
· What have you tried?
· How much did that cost you?
· Why didn’t it work?
· Who needs to have the problem solved?
· What happens if the problem is never solved?
· How much is this problem costing you per month in lost sales, increased costs, limits to growth, mitigating risks?
If they are reluctant to give you the numbers, ask the question with an intelligent guess e.g. ‘I suppose this problem could be costing you £20,000 a month in lost sales’. Usually they will correct you with something like ‘No, it’s more than that’ or ‘More like £10,000 a month’
In the conversation, restate the true implications as concrete facts: e.g. ‘So you are telling me that in a full year this problem is costing you almost a quarter of a million in lost sales and for every month you delay in addressing this problem that’s £20,000 or revenue you will never see’.
An Initial Engagement
When the time comes to discuss starting a fee-earning relationship, begin with a small piece of work as a ‘test purchase’ to build credibility, develop a roadmap to address the organisation’s systemic issues in the area of concern, and gain the insight needed to build a business case for your ongoing involvement.
You should be able to build a roadmap presentation with about 5 days of work over a couple of weeks, leading to a presentation of findings to your key stakeholders.
Seek to establish the scope, a fixed fee, the involvement required by the client and the delivery timetable verbally and agree to confirm it by email.
At this point, you want to anchor your value but be ready to discount the price. You might for example say: “This is probably about a week’s work and I would normally charge £10,000 but because it’s the first time we are working together I am happy to discount the price to £5,000”.
This does three things, it anchors your value at £2,000 a day, it establishes a pattern of fixed price for fixed scope work and it offers a price for this initial piece of work that can be agreed by the buyer without consulting on the budget implications.
After your First ‘Yes’
This initial engagement is not the destination. It provides you with the insight for you to propose an ongoing relationship at a fixed monthly fee for a fixed scope of responsibility where you are leading a function to ensure that it becomes fit for purpose as the organisation grows, develops and responds to a changing market.
Because of the disappointments you have faced and urgent need for income, you have, you may well be tempted to underprice your contribution to ensure you win an ongoing engagement. I would strongly encourage you to quote a fixed monthly fee based on the market rate (in the UK in 2026 this is between £1,000-£1,500 a day depending upon your profession) but, if you feel you need to, offer an initial discount to be reviewed after six months. Your invoices will explicitly show the market fee and the discount. You can then regularly negotiate a reduction in the discount until you achieve a full market rate.
Building on your First Client
When you offer a discount, ask for something in exchange: a testimonial, a referral, an introduction, a case study to be provided on a regular basis.
Draw on the experience to illustrate and inform conversations with you have with other potential clients or people you connect with as part of your networking.
I built a highly profitable expert witness practice, in part, by sharing stories and insights with litigation partners from different cases that I had been involved in or invited to consider. They reciprocated by sharing stories back. We always preserved client confidentiality, but the cases were often in the public domain once the courts rendered judgment. By adding my perspective, insight or distinctive point of view, I became a valuable source of market intelligence as well as building my own authority.
With encouragement,
Charles McLachlan
DM me in complete confidence on LinkedIn with the words “Scrap Heap Challenge” or write to: scrapheapchallenge@portfolioexecutive.biz